Mafia III: Definitive Edition vs Mafia
6/10Match score
Higher community rating
Mafia
+7
rating points
More player ratings
Mafia
1,509 ratings
Similarity Breakdown
Same
Game Modes
Same
Perspective
Similar
Genres
Similar
Themes
Different
Features
Shared
Game Modes
Single player
Perspective
Third person
Genres
AdventureRacingShooter
Themes
ActionOpen world
Features
italian mafianotoriety systemcrime
Key Differences
Genres
Mafia III: Definitive Edition
-Mafia
Fighting
Themes
Mafia III: Definitive Edition
Drama
Mafia
Stealth
Features
Mafia III: Definitive Edition
1960sblack marketmafiathe game awards - best narrative - nomineethe game awards - best performance - nominee
Mafia
colt detective specialfuel managementvehicle combatvehicular combatenforced speeding laws
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Mafia III: Definitive Edition | Mafia |
|---|---|---|
| Release Date | Oct 7, 2016 | Aug 29, 2002 |
| Rating | 67/100 (499 ratings) | 74/100 (1,509 ratings) |
| Genres | AdventureRacingShooter | AdventureFightingRacingShooter |
| Themes | ActionDramaOpen world | ActionOpen worldStealth |
| Features | 1960sblack marketitalian mafiamafianotoriety systemthe game awards - best narrative - nomineethe game awards - best performance - nomineethe game awards 2016war veterans4k ultra hdblack protagonistcover systemover the shoulderrevengestreet racing | colt detective specialfuel managementvehicle combatvehicular combatenforced speeding lawsroaming the countryside1930sanarchismin-game radioitalian mafianotoriety systemsex workaggressive door-openingflashbacklinear gameplay |
| Game Modes | Single player | Single player |
| Player Perspective | Third person | Third person |
| Platforms | Mac, PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 4, Xbox One | PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 2, Xbox |
Comparison Summary
Mafia III: Definitive Edition and Mafia have a 6/10 match score. Both games overlap around Single player, Third person, Adventure, Racing, Shooter, Action.
Mafia III: Definitive Edition stands out for Drama, 1960s, black market, mafia, while Mafia stands out for Fighting, Stealth, colt detective special, fuel management.
Mafia has the higher community rating in the current dataset. Players who enjoy Single player, Third person, Adventure are the most likely to find value in both.