Games Like Pony Island
Explore games similar to Pony Island, based on shared mechanics, themes, genres, and player interests.
Pony Island
⭐ 8/10$4.99
PuzzleIndiePsychological HorrorPixel GraphicsHackingSingleplayerDemonsHorror
Pony Island is a suspense puzzle game in disguise.
View Pony Island detailsSimilar Games
Ranked by precomputed similarity score from shared Steam data.
The Hex
Strong Match
⭐ 8/10
$9.99
MemesDarkGreat SoundtrackPsychological HorrorHorror
I hate this game
Strong Match
⭐ 8/10
$1.99
HackingExperimentalMemesShortGreat Soundtrack
Closure
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$9.99
ExperimentalDarkGreat SoundtrackHorrorPuzzle
eversion
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$4.99
ShortDarkPsychological HorrorHorrorPixel Graphics
Shady Part of Me
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$2.24
ShortDarkGreat SoundtrackPsychological HorrorHorror
SEPTEMBER 1999
Good Match
⭐ 0/10
Free to play
ShortGoreDarkPsychological HorrorHorror
Paranormal Night Shift
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$3.99
DemonsGoreDarkPsychological HorrorHorror
Moved In
Good Match
⭐ 7/10
$0.79
DemonsShortDarkPsychological HorrorHorror
Bem Feito
Good Match
⭐ 7/10
$5.99
GoreDarkPsychological HorrorHorrorPixel Graphics
Potatoman Seeks the Troof
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$3.99
MemesShortGreat SoundtrackFunnyPixel Graphics
How Fish Is Made
Good Match
⭐ 0/10
Free to play
ShortGoreDarkPsychological HorrorHorror
Bulb Boy
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$8.99
ShortGoreDarkPsychological HorrorHorror
Locked Up
Good Match
⭐ 6/10
$8.70
DemonsDarkGreat SoundtrackPsychological HorrorHorror
Psalm 5:9-13
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$3.99
GoreDarkPsychological HorrorHorrorPuzzle
keyg: the last prison
Good Match
⭐ 5/10
$4.99
ExperimentalShortGreat SoundtrackPuzzleStory Rich
Press Ctrl
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$1.99
Psychological HorrorFunnyPixel GraphicsPuzzleCute
DEAD LETTER DEPT.
Good Match
⭐ 9/10
$14.99
ExperimentalShortDarkPsychological HorrorHorror
Dungeon and Puzzles
Good Match
⭐ 8/10
$7.99
ExperimentalPixel GraphicsPuzzleCute2D
Mist
Good Match
⭐ 0/10
Free to play
ShortPsychological HorrorHorrorPixel GraphicsPuzzle
Museum of Monoliths
Good Match
⭐ 7/10
$2.99
ShortDarkPsychological HorrorHorrorPuzzle